What Material Should I Choose for My Deck | Deck Company Newmarket

Choosing the right material for your deck is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when planning your outdoor space. As a contractor who builds decks across York Region, I’ve worked with everything from budget-friendly builds to high-end custom projects—and the material you choose can completely change the outcome.

The Two Most Common Options: Pressure-Treated vs Composite

The two materials we install the most are pressure-treated wood and composite decking.

Pressure-treated wood is the more affordable option upfront. It’s a solid choice if you’re working within a tighter budget and still want a functional outdoor space.

Composite decking, on the other hand, is what most of our clients are choosing today—especially for larger or more custom projects. It offers a cleaner, more modern look and requires very little maintenance.

The Biggest Mistake Homeowners Make

The most common mistake I see is homeowners choosing based only on initial cost.

Pressure-treated decks may seem like the cheaper option, but over time you need to:

• Stain or seal it regularly

• Deal with potential warping or cracking

• Replace boards sooner

Composite costs more upfront, but you’re saving time, maintenance, and future repairs.

What You Should Actually Consider

Before choosing your deck material, ask yourself:

• What’s my budget?

• Do I want to maintain this every year?

• How long do I plan to stay in this home?

• Do I want a high-end look or something simple?

One question I always ask my clients is:

“Do you want something you have to maintain every year, or something you install once and forget about?”

Real Project Examples | Deck Company Newmarket

We recently completed a multi-level composite deck with glass railings for around $28,000. The client wanted something modern, clean, and completely low maintenance—and it turned out incredible.

On the other hand, we built a pressure-treated deck for about $5,000 on a lower-level space. It was a great budget-friendly solution and fit the client’s needs perfectly.

Both options worked—it just depends on your goals.

My Honest Recommendation

If your budget allows, I almost always recommend composite decking.

Deck Company Newmarket

It lasts longer, looks better over time, and eliminates the ongoing maintenance that comes with wood.

That said, pressure-treated is still a solid option if you’re trying to keep costs down or building a smaller deck.

At the end of the day:

The best deck isn’t the most expensive—it’s the one that fits your lifestyle, budget, and long-term plans.

Need Help Deciding?

If you're unsure what material is right for your project, we’re happy to help. We’ll walk you through your options and design something that fits your space and budget.

📍 Serving Newmarket, Aurora, Bradford & surrounding areas📩 Contact us for a free consultation